.jpg)
If you’re planning a custom swimming pool in Southwest Florida — from Sarasota down to Punta Gorda — one of the most common decisions you’ll face is whether to install a screen enclosure or leave your pool completely open.
As an experienced pool builder in Southwest Florida, Messina Pools helps homeowners weigh both options based on lifestyle, aesthetics, and long-term value. While screen enclosures are popular, many homeowners today are intentionally choosing no enclosure for a more open, resort-style experience.
Below, we explore the pros and cons of pool screen enclosures, while highlighting why an open pool design may be the better choice for many Southwest Florida homes.
Pros of Pool Screen Enclosures
Reduced Bugs and Debris
Screen enclosures help limit mosquitoes, no-see-ums, leaves, and pine needles from entering the pool. This can:
- Reduce skimming and vacuuming
- Keep water cleaner between service visits
- Provide comfort during peak insect seasons
Partial Sun Protection
Pool cages block a portion of UV exposure, which can reduce glare and sun intensity during midday swimming.
Added Barrier
While not a replacement for code-required safety features, enclosures can add a secondary barrier that offers peace of mind for families with pets or young children.
Cons of Pool Screen Enclosures (Why Many Homeowners Skip Them)
Visual Impact and Aesthetics
One of the biggest drawbacks of a screen enclosure is how it affects the look of your backyard. Open pools offer:
- Unobstructed views of landscaping, water, and sky
- A cleaner, more luxurious appearance
- A true resort-style feel
Many homeowners working with a custom pool builder prefer the elegance and simplicity of an open design.
Higher Upfront Cost
Screen enclosures are a major additional expense. Depending on size and design, they can add tens of thousands of dollars to a pool project — funds many homeowners prefer to invest in:
- Larger pool dimensions
- Premium finishes
- Water features, spas, or outdoor kitchens
Storm and Hurricane Risk
In Southwest Florida, storms are a serious consideration. Even code-compliant enclosures:
- Are vulnerable to hurricane damage
- Often require re-screening or structural repairs after storms
- May increase insurance exposure or premiums in some cases
An open pool eliminates this risk entirely.
Ongoing Maintenance
While enclosures reduce debris, they introduce their own maintenance needs:
- Torn or sagging screens
- Algae and dirt buildup on frames
- Periodic repairs and replacement
Open pools rely on standard pool maintenance — without an additional structure to maintain.
Limited Entertaining Experience
Many homeowners envision their pool as an extension of indoor living. An open pool provides:
- Better airflow and natural breezes
- A stronger connection to outdoor kitchens and fire features
- An ideal setting for entertaining guests
This open-air feel is difficult to replicate inside a screened structure.
Why Open Pools Are Gaining Popularity in Southwest Florida
As a trusted custom pool builder, Messina Pools has seen a growing trend toward open pool designs that emphasize:
- Clean architectural lines
- High-end finishes
- Seamless indoor–outdoor living
With modern pool automation, efficient filtration, and professional service options, many homeowners find that the benefits of an open pool far outweigh the drawbacks.
Work With a Southwest Florida Pool Builder Who Designs for Your Lifestyle
Choosing whether to install a screen enclosure is not a one-size-fits-all decision. It depends on your property, how you use your pool, and the experience you want to create.
At Messina Pools, we specialize in custom swimming pool construction throughout Sarasota, Venice, North Port, Port Charlotte, and Punta Gorda. Our design process focuses on long-term value, aesthetics, and how you truly live outdoors.
If you’re considering a new pool and want expert guidance from an experienced pool builder in Southwest Florida, contact Messina Pools today to schedule a consultation.
Your pool should feel open, inviting, and built for the Florida lifestyle.
